Списки погибших грузинских военнослужащих

[anillarionov]

Пока российские власти занимаются пропагандой, будто бы в Южной Осетии они защищали жизнь и достоинство  российских граждан, а немногие российские граждане пытаются привлечь внимание к необходимости публикации списка своих погибших сограждан:
http://aillarionov.livejournal.com/12148.html
http://zebra24.livejournal.com/135597.html,

грузинское министерство обороны опубликовало списки погибших и пропавших грузинских военнослужащих:

List of Casualties among the Georgian Military Servicemen

By the conditions of September 30, 2008

Total: 128
Officers: 11
Corporal/Sergeant: 106
Private: 1
Reservist: 9
Civilian: 1


1. Captan-Leutenant Teimuraz Chitadze – Naval Forces
2. Corporal Zviad Datuashvili – Naval Forces
3. Corporal Temur Pichkhaia – Naval Forces
4. Corporal Giorgi Gvinjilia – Naval Forces
5. Corporal Zviad Barbakadze – Naval Forces
6. Captain Albert Balkhamishvili – Air Forces
7. Sergeant Nodar Devnozashvili – Air Forces
8. Junior Sergeant Giorgi Nanuashvili – Air Forces
9. Corporal Badri Basiladze– Air Forces
10. Contracting M/S Samson Gurchiani – Air Forces
11. Corporal Shalva Trapaidze – I Infantry Brigade
12. Corporal Vitali Takadze – I Infantry Briagde
13. Corporal Mamuka Bekurashvili – I Infantry Brigade
14. Lieutenant Shota Khurtsidze – I Infantry Brigade
15. Corporal Aslan Shainidze – I Infantry Brigade
16. Corporal Tamaz Nikitin – II Infantry Brigade
17. Junior Sergeant Mamia Pantsulaia – II Infantry Brigade
18. Corporal Levan Tepania – II Infantry Brigade
19. Junior Sergeant Ednar Diasamidze – II Infantry Brigade
20. Corporal Dimitri Jailova – II Infantry Brigade
21. Corporal Temur Bokuchava – II Infantry Brigade
22. Corporal Mamuka Samakashvili – II Infantry Brigade
23. Corporal Amiran Shainidze – II Infantry Brigade
24. Corporal Malkhaz Abashidze – II Infantry Brigade
25. Corporal Balashvili Zurab – II Infantry Brigade
26. Corporal Mikheil Dvalishvili – II Infantry Brigade
27. Corporal Teimuraz Beridze – II Infantry Brigade
28. Corporal Ilia Sheklashvili – II Infantry Brigade
29. Junior Sergeant Pridon Turmanidze – II Infantry Brigade
30. Sergeant Vazha Shanidze – II Infantry Brigade
31. Junior Sergeant Anzor Geldiashvili – II Infantry Brigade
32. Junior Sergeant Levan Kokhreidze – II Infantry Brigade
33. Junior Sergeant Aleksandre Oniani – II Infantry Brigade
34. Corporal Ruslan Tsuladze – II Infantry Brigade
35. Corporal Nikoloz Porchkhidze – II Infantry Brigade
36. Corporal Shmagi Kupatadze – II Infantry Brigade
37. Corporal Zviad Katsadze – II Infantry Brigade
38. Junior Sergeant Ilia Gabunia – II Infantry Brigade
39. Corporal Irakli Janelidze – II Infantry Brigade
40. Corporal Marlen Baramia – II Infantry Brigade
41. Sergeant Levan Melkadze – II Infantry Brigade
42. Captain Leri Lagurashvili – II Infantry Brigade
43. Corporal Levan Mandzulashvili – II Infantry Brigade
44. Corporal Emzar Tsilosani - II Infantry Brigade
45. Junior Sergeant of Air Forces Peliks Kakauridze - II Infantry Brigade
46. Corporal Roman Zoidze - II Infantry Brigade
47. Junior Sergeant Zurab Epadze – III Infantry Brigade
48. Corporal Giorgi Tatuashvili – III Infantry Brigade
49. Corporal Aleksandre Zazashvili – III Infantry Brigade
50. Corporal Malkhaz Giguashvili – III Infantry Brigade
51. Corporal Avtandil Kamashidze – III Infantry Brigade
52. Corporal Koba Kharchilava – III Infantry Brigade
53. Corporal Artem Balakhashvili – III Infantry Brigade
54. Junior Sergeant Merab Tutisani – III Infantry Brigade
55. Corporal Valeri Tsitskishvili – III Infantry Brigade
56. Corporal Giga Gogorishvili – III Infantry Brigade
57. Junior Sergeant Vasili Smirnov – III Infantry Brigade
58. Junior Sergeant Paata Kopaliani – III Infantry Brigade
59. Junior Sergeant Pridon Bregadze – III Infantry Brigade
60. Senior Lieutenant Merab Akhobadze – IV Infantry Brigade
61. Captain Koba Sergia – IV Infantry Brigade
62. Corporal Giorgi Tsikarishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
63. Major Shalva Dolidze – IV Infantry Brigade
64. Sergeant Pilipe Mgaloblishvili – IV Infantry Brigade
65. Senior Lieutenant Ilia Babutsidze – IV Infantry Brigade
66. Corporal Levan Devdariani - IV Infantry Brigade
67. Corporal Irakli Bazadze - IV Infantry Brigade
68. Corporal Zaur Tenieshvili - IV Infantry Brigade
69. Corporal Avedik Lomidze - IV Infantry Brigade
70. Corporal Nika Kalabegashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
71. Corporal Davit Jikia - IV Infantry Brigade
72. Corporal Saba Dadvani - IV Infantry Brigade
73. Corporal Murtaz Iremadze - IV Infantry Brigade
74. Corporal Vakhtang Gzirishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
75. Corporal Davit Dvalishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
76. Corporal Onise Doijashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
77. Corporal Raul Mzhavanadze - IV Infantry Brigade
78. Corporal Devi Chaduneli - IV Infantry Brigade
79. Corporal Gogita Karchava – IV Infantry Brigade
80. Corporal Zaur Makharashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
81. Corporal Koba Tsurtsumia - IV Infantry Brigade
82. Corporal Giorgi Javakhadze - IV Infantry Brigade
83. Corporal Soso Gviniashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
84. Corporal Giorgi Berikashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
85. Corporal Vladimer Davitashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
86. Senior Sergeant Zaza Peridze - IV Infantry Brigade
87. Junior Sergeant Ushangi Sopromadze – I Infantry Brigade
88. Major Gela Chedia – V Infantry Brigade
89. Sergeant Merab Chelidze – V Infantry Brigade, Medical Service
90. Corporal Giorgi Gviniashvili – V Infantry Brigade
91. Corporal Amiran Mamaladze – V Infantry Brigade
92. Corporal Jimsher Toroshelidze – Military Engineering Brigade
93. Corporal Giorgi Muradashvili – Military Engineering Brigade
94. Sergeant Zaza Akhalkatsi – Military Engineering Brigade
95. Col. DaviT Elizbarashvili – Military Engineering Brigade
96. Senior Sergeant Archil Berianidze – Separate Tank Battalion
97. Sergeant Giorgi Badriashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
98. Senior Sergeant Tamaz Melikidze - Separate Tank Battalion
99. Corporal Ivane Kvaliashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
100. Corporal Vasil Ganjelashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
101. Corporal Giorgi Romelashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
102. Corporal Zaza Dotiashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
103. Corporal Jimsher Kurdgelashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
104. Corporal Giorgi Mamukashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
105. Corporal Zakaria Kvirikashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
106. Sergeant Elguja Inauri - Separate Tank Battalion
107. Corporal Zurab Urigashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
108. Corporal Ioseb Mekhaturishvili - Separate Tank Battalion
109. Corporal Mzechabuk Michitashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
110. Corporal Ramaz Eremashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
111. Corporal Gizo Tsulaia - Separate Tank Battalion
112. Corporal Ivane Elikashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
113. Senior Sergeant Gogita Makrakhidze - Separate Tank Battalion
114. Corporal Otar Kareli - Separate Tank Battalion
115. Sergeant Mikheil Tsertsvadze - Separate Tank Battalion
116. Corporal Giorgi Shanidze – Separate Light Infantry Battalion
117. Junior Sergeant Omar Aslanidze - Separate Light Infantry Battalion
118. Sergeant Kakhaber Tavgorashvili – Special Forces Brigade
119. Civilian Amiran Razmadze – Logistic Support Department of Army
120. Reservist Data Khutsilava – National Guard
121. Reservist Goga Chitanava - National Guard
122. Reservist Otar Kikalishvili - National Guard
123. Reservist Shalva Gabunia - National Guard
124. Reservist Goga Beraia - National Guard
125. Reservist Mikheil Iosava - National Guard
126. Reservist Levan Chochua - National Guard
127. Reservist Irakli Morbedadze - National Guard
128. Reservist Zaza Bochoidze - National Guard

List of the Missing Georgian Military Servicemen

By the Conditions of September 30, 2008

Total: 41
Officers: 11
Corporal/Sergeants: 30


1. Captain Giorgi Jojua – IV Infantry Brigade
3. Senior Sergeant Giorgi Antsukhelidze - IV Infantry Brigade
3. Corporal Davit Bliadze – IV Infantry Brigade
4. Corporal Rezo Alaverdashvili – IV Infantry Brigade
5. Corporal Levan Midelashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
6. Corporal Tariel Kamashidze - IV Infantry Brigade
7. Corporal Levan Iosebidze - IV Infantry Brigade
8. Corporal Shmagi Khaikashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
9. Corporal Rezo Akhalkatsi - IV Infantry Brigade
10. Sergeant Zurab Turashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
11. Corporal Shmagi Nozadze - IV Infantry Brigade
12. Corporal Zaza Glunchadze - IV Infantry Brigade
13. Junior Lieutenant Zurab Begiashvili - IV Infantry Brigade, Medical Service
14. Junior Sergeant Gocha Danelia - IV Infantry Brigade
15. Corporal Giorgi Katamadze - IV Infantry Brigade
16. Senior Sergeant Gela Tigishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
17. Senior Lieutenant Aleksi Natroshvili - IV Infantry Brigade
18. Lieutenant Rezo Mamisashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
19. Senior Lieutenant Sergo Melia - IV Infantry Brigade
20. Senior Lieutenant Giorgi Nadareishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
21. Captain Erekle Kuloshvili - IV Infantry Brigade
22. Captain Aleksandre Tandashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
23. Junior Sergeant Gela Mebagishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
24. Lieutenant Alia Bardavelidze - IV Infantry Brigade
25. Captain Giorgi Kirakozashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
26. Corporal Roman Ugrekhelidze - IV Infantry Brigade
27. Corporal Zurab Abramishvili - IV Infantry Brigade
28. Corporal Sergei Gorozia - IV Infantry Brigade
29. Corporal Ioseb Bezhuashvili - IV Infantry Brigade
30. Senior Sergeant Zurab Nachkebia - IV Infantry Brigade
31. Corporal Tengiz Chagalidze – V Infantry Brigade
32. Corporal Kakhaber Khubuluri - IV Infantry Brigade
33. Lieutenant Giorgi Romelashvili – Separate Tank Battalion
34. Corporal Zaza Birtvelashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
35. Corporal Sukhitashvili Otar - Separate Tank Battalion
36. Corporal Oleg Chonishvili - Separate Tank Battalion
37. Corporal Gela Romelashvili - Separate Tank Battalion
38. Corporal Badri Berandze – I Infantry Brigade
39. Captain Vepkhvia Jishkariani – II Infantry Brigade
40. Junior Sergeant Valeri Gognadze – II Infantry Brigade
41. Corporal Kakha Koshadze - II Infantry Brigade
http://www.mod.gov.ge/2008/list/sia-E.html

В журналах ra2005 и olegpanfilov2 есть обсуждение:
http://ra2005.livejournal.com/187678.html
http://olegpanfilov2.livejournal.com/115493.html

Спасибо bbb за наводку.

Comments

[ex-dreamy-z.livejournal.com]

Некоторые категории потерь в корейской войне засекречены США до сих пор (наши открыты все). Так что открытость этой информации не так уж коррелирует с демократичностью и либеральностью.

[aillarionov.livejournal.com]

Пост, если Вы заметили, был не о США и не о демократичности и либеральности.

[ex-dreamy-z.livejournal.com]

Мне показалось, что было сравнение российских и грузинских властей, которое дает позитивную оценку грузинской стороне и негативную российской, на основе критерия публикации списков погибших. Мне хотелось уточнить что такое сравнение возможно провести также между США и Россией и по некоторым войнам оно будет в пользу СССР/РФ. Также можно обвинить США в пропаганде для достижения нужного эффекта.

[aillarionov.livejournal.com]

В первом Вы правы - было сравнение грузинский и российских властей.

Переход же от первого ко второму мне кажется натянутым.

Нынешняя Россия, Россия 2000-х, далеко не во всем является наследницей даже России 1990-х. Тем более СССР.

Нынешняя же Грузия ни в коей мере не является наследницей/представительницей/заменительницей США.

[dimon-trigger.livejournal.com]

в США не могут быть секретными никакие потери.

[nowname.livejournal.com]

Вы бы гуглем воспользовались, а? Этих опубликованных списков до буя.
Чем вас этот не устраивает, к примеру?
http://www.army.lv/?s=2550&id=4146
Список погибших миротворцев (15 человек) тоже имеется.
У вас к чему/кому претензии-то?
И почему вы думаете, что российское общество крайне заинтересовано в обнародовании списка погибших грузин, причем на английском языке?

Саакашвили

[zzpro.livejournal.com]

Может вас заинтересует ув. Андрей.

Несколько дней назад Саакашвили выступал перед Объедененным штабом. Это выступление транслировалось по телевидению. Ссылка на видефайл (на грузинском) - http://rapidshare.com/files/150691873/shexvedra_magalchinosnebtan.wmv

Перевод с грузинского (корявый, но старался близко к тексту) - http://community.livejournal.com/georgian_war/503564.html

[auraz.livejournal.com]

то что русские не опубликовали - грустно (

[beastorizer.livejournal.com]

Да, не то слово. Обидно за державу...

[beastorizer.livejournal.com]

А более точных/свежих списков нет ещё?
41 пропавших без вести - это много.